Dark mode isn’t just a trendy toggle anymore. It has become a staple in modern UI and UX design—used in everything from developer tools to finance apps, eCommerce platforms, and even productivity software. But while it may look sleek and sophisticated, designing a proper dark mode experience is more than just inverting colors or turning the background black. If done wrong, it can strain the eyes, break accessibility rules, and even push users away. So in this article, I’ll walk you through dark mode design best practices for legibility and comfort, drawing from real-world use cases, visual ergonomics research, and common design pitfalls.

Let’s get into how to actually make a dark mode that people want to use—not just something that ticks a feature checkbox.

Why Dark Mode Became So Popular

Before jumping into the how, let’s talk about the why. Why is dark mode everywhere?

Well, the most common reasons users cite are:

• Reduced eye strain in low-light environments
• Aesthetic preference
• Potential battery savings on OLED screens
• Less distraction and better focus

All of those are solid reasons. But for designers, the real challenge is meeting those user expectations without sacrificing readability or usability. Because here’s the thing—just because it’s dark doesn’t mean it’s easier to read.

Let’s now break down how to actually get dark mode right.

1. Start with a Thoughtful Color Palette

When designing dark mode, don’t just flip white to black. True dark mode design starts with a deliberate, low-luminance color palette.

Here’s what to keep in mind:

• Use dark greys, not pure black (#000). A color like #121212 or #1E1E1E is gentler on the eyes.
• Create a hierarchy of greys for backgrounds, surfaces, borders, and shadows.
• Avoid oversaturation—bright colors on a dark background can “vibrate” or glow.
• Reserve your brightest values (white or near-white) for important content like text.

Think of your dark theme as a dimly lit room. You still want clarity and contrast, but with softness. Pure black and pure white don’t belong in that room.

2. Text Color: It’s All About Contrast and Comfort

This is one of the most common mistakes: designers using white text on a black background and thinking it’s good enough. But high-contrast white text (#FFFFFF) on black is actually too bright and causes halos and blur.

Instead:

• Use off-white text like #E0E0E0 or #DADADA to reduce glare
• Stick to a contrast ratio between 7:1 and 15:1 depending on the text size and background
• Use muted greys for secondary or tertiary text

Also, make sure your typefaces remain legible at smaller sizes in dark mode. Some fonts look bolder in the dark, while others may seem thinner or washed out.

If you really want to nail dark mode design best practices for legibility and comfort, you need to test your typography under different lighting conditions.

3. Avoid Pure Black UI Elements (Seriously)

Even though black seems like the go-to for a dark theme, pure black often creates harsh edges and leads to poor depth perception. It also can make UIs look flat and “lifeless.”

Instead:

• Use very dark greys (#121212, #181818) for primary backgrounds
• Introduce slightly lighter greys (#2C2C2C, #333333) for secondary surfaces
• Allow color layering to establish depth

A subtle background gradient or shadow on modals and cards also helps them stand out without being harsh. And it makes your UI feel more polished and complete.

4. Don’t Forget Accessibility

Just because something looks good doesn’t mean everyone can use it.

Some users are visually impaired or colorblind. Dark mode should follow all the same WCAG guidelines as light mode:

• Minimum contrast ratios of 4.5:1 for normal text and 3:1 for large text
• No critical color information communicated only by hue (e.g., red = error)
• Accessible toggles for switching between light and dark modes

Also, consider user preferences. If someone’s device or browser has dark mode enabled, respect that with prefers-color-scheme: dark in your CSS.

And offer a manual toggle—some users want the choice regardless of system settings.

5. Rethink Shadows and Elevation

Shadows behave differently in dark mode.

Why? Because in light mode, shadows are darker than the background. But in dark mode, there’s no way to go darker than black. So instead, we use light glows or elevated light surfaces to simulate depth.

Try this:

• Use light-colored shadows with low opacity (rgba(255, 255, 255, 0.05))
• Introduce soft borders instead of drop shadows
• Emphasize depth through contrast and spacing, not just effects

Material Design does this well—it shifts elevation by adjusting the surface color and not just adding shadows. You should too.

6. Think About Emotions and Tone

Color psychology works differently in dark mode. Bright reds can seem aggressive. Neon greens feel unnatural. Blues can look icy or cold.

Instead:

• Use muted or pastel tones as accent colors
• Add a splash of warmth with oranges, purples, or muted golds
• Don’t overuse color—minimalism works better in dark environments

Also, test how your primary brand colors appear on a dark background. You may need to tweak them specifically for dark mode use.

7. Icons and Illustrations Need Reworking Too

Icons designed for light backgrounds often disappear or become too bold in dark mode.

So:

• Use dual icon sets, or make icons inverted-aware
• Make sure icons have enough stroke weight and contrast
• Avoid using icons that rely solely on outline unless they’re high contrast

And if you use illustrations, adapt their palette for the dark. That could mean reducing brightness, changing fills, or adjusting shadows.

8. Test in Real Environments

Testing in Figma or a design tool is not enough. Try your design:

• In low-light settings (e.g., nighttime on a phone)
• On different screens (OLED, LCD, low-res monitors)
• With visual impairments enabled (e.g., grayscale mode)

Also, invite real users to test the dark mode experience. Notice how quickly they adjust, how easily they navigate, and whether they find anything “off.”

Real comfort can’t be measured in code—it has to be felt.

9. Give Users Control and Consistency

Some users prefer dark mode all the time. Some hate it. And some like it at night only.

So provide a clear toggle. Make it easy to find. And keep it consistent across devices.

Also, persist user preference using localStorage or cookies. There’s nothing more annoying than switching dark mode on, then seeing it revert next time you visit.

Bonus: make the transition between modes smooth. No one likes a jarring flicker.

10. Real World Examples (Good and Bad)

Good:

• Apple’s dark mode is perhaps the gold standard—especially on macOS and iOS. They use soft greys, maintain depth, and provide consistent experience across all apps.
• Notion’s dark mode is clean, distraction-free, and easy to read for long periods.
• Slack lets you pick from multiple dark themes, catering to different eyes.

Bad:

• Some banking apps turn everything pure black, with neon green text—horrible contrast and strain-inducing.
• Others forget to change chart colors, leading to invisible graphs or unreadable legends.

Learning from both successes and failures helps shape your approach.

11. How We Use Dark Mode in Our Own Projects

At Flamincode, we always design light and dark modes simultaneously. Not as an afterthought. That way, we avoid the common trap of trying to “reverse engineer” dark mode later.

We:

• Build color tokens for both themes
• Use style systems that toggle themes globally
• Design illustrations and icons with adaptive palettes
• Let the user switch between modes without losing their session state

And most importantly—we test, test, test. Because dark mode done wrong can ruin the best UX.

12. Final Thoughts

Dark mode isn’t just a design trend—it’s a usability feature. When done right, it improves focus, reduces fatigue, and gives your product a modern, polished feel. But it’s not magic. It takes careful design, thoughtful testing, and a deep understanding of visual comfort.

So next time you’re working on a UI, remember: dark mode design best practices for legibility and comfort aren’t optional—they’re essential.

FAQs

1. Is dark mode better for your eyes?
It can reduce eye strain in low-light environments, but isn’t always better for long reading sessions.

2. Should all apps have dark mode?
Not necessarily, but users now expect it—especially for productivity, dev, and reading-focused tools.

3. What’s the ideal background color for dark mode?
Dark grey like #121212 or #1E1E1E is usually best—not pure black.

4. Do I need separate colors for dark mode?
Yes, you should define a separate palette or use a theme system that supports dark-specific tokens.

5. Can dark mode save battery?
On OLED screens, yes. Dark pixels use less power than light ones.

---